What is the use of a blog without pictures?

Latest First Next Previous About This Site (and me) Home page Table of Contents Contact

Options

Earliest first

Don't show social entries

Don't show personal entries

Don't show creative entries

Number of entries to display:

Start date: //

End date: //

Free will - an irrelevant argument

Arguably one of the most broadly debated subjects of all time would have to be that of whether we have free will or not. I will assume some basic universality, in that whichever position applies, applies to all. Some basic positions include:

  • Each individual has complete control over their actions and is responsible for the consequences.
  • Each individual reacts automatically to external stimuli and suffers the consequences for their actions.
  • There is no free will - each individual is controlled by some higher power and so cannot be held accountable for their actions. This position is commonly held by American litigants.
  • There is no free will, as in the third point, but the consequences are as in the second point.
  • Obviously, we have no way of determining which is true. Any test to see whether we have free will could naturally be corrupted by the higher power giving the same answer. Or corrupted by us freely choosing to believe that we are not responsible. So ultimately this is really just an argument to give philosophers something to do. It serves no materialistic or spiritual benefit, but the answer is 42.

    Firstly, lets assume that someone is begging for an immunity from consequences because they believe the third point is the truth, and that some higher power controls them. This can be dealt with by the inflicter-of-consequences also claiming that they are being controlled to inflict the consequences. If you walk in front of a moving vehicle, the consequences are the same whether you have free will or not, so, whatever your position on free will, you suffer the consequences of your actions.

    I will also point out the following on the experiment. Regardless of what position you take, if you are prepared to try it, you may, well, find your name entered here.

    So, ultimately, we have established that you suffer the consequences of your actions, and you can't tell whether you have free will or not.

    Personally, I discount the automata theory, and choose to define "me" as the power in control of my actions. Html coded to give this: me. If I have free will, then I suffer whatever consequences. If my body is just a puppet, controlled by some greater power, then I am a part of the greater power, which therefore means that I have free will, but raises a question as to who I am.

    I wonder whether Kermit believed in Jim Henson

    Comments

    Insert comments

    Please feel free to comment. I value dialogue and want other people's involvement. Please put your email address in. I will publish pretty much any comment which is made, but if you do not give your email address, I reserve the right not to publish your comment. I will not pass on or publish an email address (unless you specifically ask me to), but I may want to verify details, and cannot do this without an email address. Besides, its polite. Also, feel free to put in html tags. If you don't, I will stick them in, but I will just stick in simple ones. If you want anything more, you'll have to do it yourself.

    Your name:

    Your e-mail address:

    Your webpage:

    Public comments:

    Private comments:

    Rorschach test: What do you see in this picture (compulsory, but won't be published with your name)?

    Rorschach pic

    This is not spam

    Links

    Recent entries

    "There's Klingons on the starboard bow"

    "What's verse - it's the end of paternity leave"

    "Mark - the first week"

    "Mark - part 2"

    "Mark Gerald Allen Lubansky - the birth"

    My favourite procrastinations

    Rev's page

    Guido's musings about soccer, politics etc in Australia

    The Head Heeb - Jonathan provides a balanced view on various Israeli and (former) colonial states in less developed regions of the world.

    The Bladder - a sports satire site. Well worth a look.

    Other stuff

    << List
    Jewish Bloggers
    Join >>

    The comprehensive history project